Is `eval`ing in a CPAN module without localizing $@ a bug?
Posted
by rassie
on Stack Overflow
See other posts from Stack Overflow
or by rassie
Published on 2010-06-01T12:13:33Z
Indexed on
2010/06/01
15:43 UTC
Read the original article
Hit count: 211
I think I've encountered a bug in Params::Validate
, but I'm not sure whether I identified the problematic code piece correctly. The code in question failed to pass exceptions up the chain (using Try::Tiny
), so I started debugging and found out that a class used inside the try
block has a destructor. This destructor calls object methods which use Params::Validate
and looking into Validate.pm
source I see an eval
without $@
localization, i.e. the global $@
gets overwritten.
Now I see two options:
Params::Validate
should always localize$@
and thus it's a bug that should be reported.- The bug is in the class in question, because it shouldn't use
Params::Validate
in a destructor.Params::Validate
can stay as it is now.
Which one is it? How I should I handle this situation?
PS: I think that CPAN modules should be rock-solid and neither break themselves nor their environment, hence the question title.
© Stack Overflow or respective owner